Fashion Revue Rubrics
In order to assist you in creating a successful project for Fashion Revue, please review the following Judging Rubrics divided by skill level. If you have trouble viewing them properly please contact sara.conant@maine.edu to receive an emailed copy. Cloverbuds will receive a comment sheet with their project.
Beginner Judging Sheets for Fashion Revue Number__________________________________
| Construction (60 points) | Possible Score | Your Score | Comments |
| Fabrics/yarns – type and design suitable to pattern design | 15 | ||
| Cutting – accurate, on-grain; Knit/crocheted-no dropped, twisted, or split stitches or unintentional holes. | 15 | ||
| Stitching – correct tension, stitch length, straight stitching, correct thread and needle size, correct knitting needle, or crochet hook size, evenness of knit/crocheted items, neatness | 15 | ||
| Seams; uniform width, straight, durable, hem appropriate length for the outfit; knit/crocheted – ends bound in neatly and securely, bind off is neat and not too tight or loose. | 15 | ||
| Modeling (15 points) | |||
| Good posture, well poised | 5 | ||
| Self-presentation | 5 | ||
| Well groomed | 5 | ||
| Outfit on Person/Item in Use (25 points) | |||
| Item shows thoughtful, functional design and is well-suited to the intended use. If wearable, outfit is well-fitted and comfortable. | 10 | ||
| Item harmonizes in color and style for intended use. If wearable, item is becoming to the participant. | 10 | ||
| Item is clean | 5 | ||
| Total | 100 |
Intermediate WITH Fasteners Judging Sheet for Fashion Revue Number_______________
Intermediate Judging Sheet for Fashion Revue WITH Fasteners
Number_______________
| Construction (60 points) | Possible Score | Your Score | Comments |
| Fabrics/yarns – type and design suitable to pattern design | 5 | ||
| Cutting – accurate, on-grain; Knit or crocheted-no dropped, twisted, or split stitches or unintentional holes, | 5 | ||
| Stitching – correct tension, stitch length, straight stitching, correct thread and needle size, correct knitting needle, or crochet hook size, evenness of knit/crocheted items, neatness | 10 | ||
| Seams/hems – uniform width, straight, durable, hem appropriate length for the outfit; Knit or crocheted – ends bound in neatly and securely, new yarns joined inconspicuously, bind off not too tight or too loose. | 10 | ||
| Pressing/blocking – darts/seams pressed in correct direction, item neatly pressed, knit or crocheted items blocked or appropriately matched up for a neat finish. | 10 | ||
| Fasteners – zippers, buttons, buttonholes, hook and eye, snaps, etc. neatly installed. | 10 | ||
| Finishes – trim, decorative top-stitching, lace, linings, borders, beadwork, pockets, and flaps, etc. neatly constructed. Knit or crocheted – use of colors, different types of stitches besides knit and purl such as cabling, yarn overs for lace look, decreasing and increasing. | 10 | ||
| Modeling (15 points) | |||
| Good posture, well poised | 5 | ||
| Self-presentation | 5 | ||
| Well groomed | 5 | ||
| Outfit on Person/Item in Use (25 points) | |||
| Item clean | 5 | ||
| Shows thoughtful, functional design. If wearable, outfit is well-fitted and comfortable | 10 | ||
| Item harmonizes in color and style for intended use. | 5 | ||
| Item suited to accessories/outfit, occasion, and participant. | 5 | ||
| Total (100 – 85 Blue, 84 – 70 Red, Below 70 White) | 100 |
Intermediate Judging Sheet for Fashion Revue WITHOUT Fasteners Number_______________
| Construction (60 points) | Possible Score | Your Score | Comments |
| Fabrics/yarns – type and design suitable to pattern design | 5 | ||
| Cutting – accurate, on-grain; Knit or crocheted-no dropped, twisted, or split stitches or unintentional holes, | 5 | ||
| Stitching – correct tension, stitch length, straight stitching, correct thread and needle size, correct knitting needle, or crochet hook size, evenness of knit/crocheted items, neatness | 10 | ||
| Seams/hems – uniform width, straight, durable, hem appropriate length for the outfit. Knit or Crochet – ends bound in neatly and securely, new yarns joined inconspicuously, bind off is neat and not too tight or loose. | 10 | ||
| Pressing/blocking – darts/seams pressed in correct direction, item neatly pressed, knit or crocheted items blocked or appropriately matched up for a neat finish. | 10 | ||
| Personalization, Creativity, Improvisation | 10 | ||
| Finishes – trim, decorative top-stitching, lace, linings, borders, beadwork, pockets, and flaps, etc. neatly constructed. Knit or crocheted – use of colors, different types of stitches besides knit and purl such as cabling, yarn overs for lace look, decreasing and increasing. | 10 | ||
| Modeling (15 points) | |||
| Good posture, well poised | 5 | ||
| Self-presentation | 5 | ||
| Well groomed | 5 | ||
| Outfit on Person/Item in Use (25 points) | |||
| Item clean | 5 | ||
| Shows thoughtful, functional design. If wearable, outfit is well-fitted and comfortable | 10 | ||
| Item harmonizes in color and style for intended use. | 5 | ||
| Item suited to accessories/outfit, occasion, and participant. | 5 | ||
| Total (100 – 85 Blue, 84 – 70 Red, Below 70 White) | 100 |
Advanced Judging Sheet for Fashion Revue WITH Fasteners
Number_______________
| Construction (60 Points) | Possible Score | Your Score | Comments |
| Looks professional (neat) | 10 | ||
| Complexity of pattern | 10 | ||
| Stitching – correct tension, stitch length, straight stitching, correct thread and needle size, correct knitting needle, or crochet hook size, evenness of knit/crocheted items, neatness | 10 | ||
| Pressing/blocking – darts/seams pressed in correct direction, item neatly pressed, knit or crocheted items blocked or appropriately matched up for a neat finish. | 5 | ||
| Cutting – Accurate, cut on-grain; knit or crochet stitches neat, multiple yarns carried/joined inconspicuously, no dropped, twisted, or split stitches or unintentional holes | 5 | ||
| Seams/hems; uniform width, straight, durable, hem appropriate length for the outfit; knitted or crocheted – ends bound in neatly and securely, new yarns joined inconspicuously, bind off not too tight or too loose | 5 | ||
| Fasteners – zippers, buttons, buttonholes, hook and eye, snaps, etc. neatly installed. | 5 | ||
| Finishes -trim, decorative top-stitching, lace linings, borders, beadwork, pockets, and flaps, etc. neatly constructed; knit or crocheted – different types of stitches such as cabling, yarn overs to make lace, decreases and increases, any add-ons. | 5 | ||
| Fabric/yarn selection; type and design suitable for pattern design | 5 | ||
| Modeling (20 Points) | |||
| Self-presentation | 10 | ||
| Well poised, good posture | 5 | ||
| Well groomed | 5 | ||
| Outfit on Person/Project in Use (20 Points) | |||
| Shows thoughtful, functional design. If wearable, outfit is well-fitted and comfortable | 8 | ||
| Item harmonizes in color and style for intended use | 4 | ||
| Item suited to accessories/outfit, occasion, and participant | 3 | ||
| Appropriate ease for garment style (i.e. correct fit at neck, shoulders, chest, waist, hips) or in non-wearable, suiting size and conformation to use. | 3 | ||
| Clean | 2 | ||
| Total (100 – 85 Blue, 84 – 70 Red, Below 70 White) | 100 |
Advanced Judging Sheet for Fashion Revue WITHOUT Fasteners Number_______________
| Construction (60 Points) | Possible Score | Your Score | Comments |
| Looks professional (neat) | 10 | ||
| Complexity of pattern | 10 | ||
| Stitching – correct tension, stitch length, straight stitching, correct thread and needle size, correct knitting needle, or crochet hook size, evenness of knit/crocheted items, neatness | 10 | ||
| Pressing/blocking – darts/seams pressed in correct direction, item neatly pressed, knit or crocheted items blocked or appropriately matched up for a neat finish. | 5 | ||
| Cutting – Accurate, cut on-grain; knit or crochet stitches neat, multiple yarns carried/joined inconspicuously, no dropped, twisted, or split stitches or unintentional holes | 5 | ||
| Seams/hems; uniform width, straight, durable, hem appropriate length for the outfit; knit or crocheted – ends bound in neatly and securely, new yarns joined inconspicuously, bind off not to tight or too loose. | 5 | ||
| Personalization, Creativity, and Improvisation. | 5 | ||
| Finishes -Trim, decorative top-stitching, lace linings, borders, beadwork, pockets, and flaps, etc. neatly constructed; Knit or crocheted – different types of stitches such as cabling, yarn over to make lace, decreasing and increasing, any add-ons | 5 | ||
| Fabric/yarn selection; type and design suitable for pattern design | 5 | ||
| Modeling (20 Points) | |||
| Self-presentation | 10 | ||
| Well poised, good posture | 5 | ||
| Well groomed | 5 | ||
| Outfit on Person/Project in Use (20 Points) | |||
| Shows thoughtful, functional design. If wearable, outfit is well-fitted and comfortable | 8 | ||
| Item harmonizes in color and style for intended use | 4 | ||
| Item suited to accessories/outfit, occasion, and participant | 3 | ||
| Appropriate ease for garment style (i.e. correct fit at neck, shoulders, chest, waist, hips) or in non-wearable, suiting size and conformation to use. | 3 | ||
| Clean | 2 | ||
| Total (100 – 85 Blue, 84 – 70 Red, Below 70 White) | 100 |
4‐H Fashion Revue REFASHIONED Category Scorecard
Contestant Number: ________________ ¨ Blue 28-22 ¨ Red 21-16 ¨ White 15 and lower
| Distinguished 4 | Proficient
3 |
Developing
2 |
Emerging
1 |
Score | |
| EXHIBITOR | |||||
| Self Esteem
Poise/Posture
|
Exhibits confidence. Self-assured. Models garment/item to its best advantage. Good use of gestures and facial expressions. | Confident. Poised and graceful with good posture. Appropriate use of gestures and facial expressions. | Presents garment/item with some enthusiasm and poise. Limited facial expressions | Appears awkward or uncomfortable when presenting garment /item. Additional practice will help increase confidence. | |
|
Personal presentation/ Grooming |
Fresh and well groomed. Neat in appearance. Skin, hair, nails clean and well cared for. Shoes spotless and in good condition. | Well groomed. Neat in appearance. Skin, hair, nails clean. Shoes clean and in good shape. | Neat in appearance. Skin, hair and nails clean. Shoes need attention. | Appearance needs more attention: skin, hair, nails and/or shoes are untidy or soiled. | |
|
Verbal Communication Interaction with Judges |
Thorough knowledge of construction techniques, garment/item care, fabric and fiber content, cost. Engages confidently with judges. Makes full eye contact. | Able to answer questions regarding garment/item care, fabric content, construction techniques. Engages with judges. Makes eye contact. | Basic knowledge of construction techniques and garment/item care. Limited eye contact and engagement with judges. | Able to answer questions with prompting but nervousness prevents further engagement with judges. | |
| GARMENT(S)/ITEM | |||||
|
Creativity & Originality |
Outstanding vision in designing garment/item and accessory. Unusual and original techniques used to enhance the design. Demonstrates inventive skills. | Good design elements. Creative techniques used to refashion garment/item and accessory. Competent use of imagination. | Fabric and trim enhance the design though innovation lacking in most aspects of the garment/item and/or accessory. | Little innovation shown in design, detail, fit or flair of final garment/item and accessory. | |
|
Process of Reconstruction |
Imaginative use of garment(s)/item and original materials. Totally remade original articles. | Garment/item well designed. Mostly remade original articles. | Some creativity used. Lacks much change from original garment(s)/item. | Original garment/item minimally refashioned | |
| Workmanship
as it relates to outside appearance |
Well‐constructed and
will wear well. Construction detail suited to style and fabric. Grain line maintained. Clean and well pressed. |
Minor construction flaws which do not affect the overall appearance or durability of the garment/item. Clean and pressed. | Construction techniques show. Noticeable defects affect appearance and durability. | Garment/item not stable. Garment/item has major defects that detract from overall appearance. Needs better pressing. Clip loose threads. | |
| Coordinated total look
|
Garment/item overall looks well put together. Design and/or pattern making skills used. All design elements are balanced. Accessories enhance the outfit/item. | Garment/item compliments the model. Design relates well to style, color, and texture. Accessories are coordinated. | Garment/item suitable for model. Design elements add some interest to outfit/item. Accessories add little interest to outfit/item. | Garment/item looks incomplete or poor fitting. The relative proportion of various design elements is not cohesive. | |
| TOTAL POINTS | |||||
¨ Disqualification: Fabric source not refashioned into a new and distinctive garment. Only alteration used for new garment.
Modified from Montana 4-H
Comments (use back of page for more):